TripStow
EYW to LGA

Key West to New York flights

Flights from Key West (EYW) to New York (LGA) cover 1,947 km. In the last 12 months there were 359 scheduled flights on 2 airlines; 72% arrived within 15 minutes of schedule and the average flight arrives about 18 minutes late. Republic Airways was the most punctual, with 73% on time.

359
flights in 12 months
72%
on time (within 15 min)
+18 min
average arrival vs schedule
1,947 km
distance

Flying Key West to New York soon? Forward your booking to TripStow and get a check-in reminder, plus the trip on your travel map. Free.

Month by month

Over the last 7 months, Key West to New York ran best in April 2026 (83.3% on time) and worst in December 2025 (56.1%).

Share of EYW to LGA flights arriving within 15 minutes of schedule, by month. Green is the best month, orange the worst.
See the figures
MonthOn timeCancelledFlights
November 202573%2.9%34
December 202556%8.9%45
January 202677%11.3%62
February 202667%10.7%56
March 202663%9.7%62
April 202683%0%60
May 202679%0%40

Why flights on this route are delayed

Most delay time on Key West to New York flights came from the airline itself (38% of delay minutes), then the plane arriving late from its previous flight (32%).

  1. The airline (crew, maintenance, boarding, fuelling)38%
  2. The plane arriving late from its previous flight32%
  3. Air traffic control and airport congestion26%
  4. Severe weather3%

Share of delay minutes on flights that arrived 15 minutes or more late, by the cause airlines report to the US Department of Transportation, over the last 12 months.

Best day of the week to fly

Tuesday is the most punctual day for Key West to New York flights (84% on time) and Sunday the least (47%).

  1. Monday68% on time41 flights
  2. Tuesday84% on time44 flights
  3. Wednesday79% on time47 flights
  4. Thursday77% on time48 flights
  5. Friday83% on time48 flights
  6. Saturday62% on time50 flights
  7. Sunday47% on time43 flights

Share of flights arriving within 15 minutes of schedule, by day of departure, over the last 12 months of US DOT data.

Airlines on this route

US airlines' domestic flights, last 12 months. Source: US Bureau of Transportation Statistics, public domain.

Coming back? New York to Key West flights. More about Key West (EYW) and New York (LGA).

Questions and answers

Are flights from Key West to New York usually on time?
72% of the 359 flights from EYW to LGA in the last 12 months arrived within 15 minutes of schedule, 5.6 points below the US average of 77.3%. Flights arrived about 18 minutes late on average.
Which airlines fly from Key West to New York?
2 US airlines flew EYW to LGA in the last 12 months: Republic Airways (343 flights), Delta Air Lines (16 flights).
Which airline is most punctual from Key West to New York?
Republic Airways, with 73% of its flights arriving within 15 minutes of schedule in the last 12 months, against 72% for the route as a whole. Only airlines with at least 50 flights on the route are compared.
How far is it from Key West to New York by air?
1,947 km (1,210 miles), measured as the great-circle distance between EYW and LGA.
What is the best month to fly Key West to New York?
Over the last 7 months, Key West to New York ran best in April 2026 (83.3% on time) and worst in December 2025 (56.1%). The month-by-month figures are on this page.
What is the best day to fly Key West to New York?
Tuesday is the most punctual day for Key West to New York flights (84% on time) and Sunday the least (47%).
Why are Key West to New York flights delayed?
Most delay time on Key West to New York flights came from the airline itself (38% of delay minutes), then the plane arriving late from its previous flight (32%).

Flying Key West to New York soon?

Forward your booking and TripStow builds your trip, reminds you when check-in opens and shows how your flight usually runs. Free.

Start your map, free